Index fund portfolio construction. No yawning, this is important stuff

For the main topic today, I want to follow up on one of the early newsletters of the year, in which we had discussed what an index fund is. (see here for a refresher). Once you understand how an index fund works, and why it exists, you are emerging from the mutual fund swamp, but you are not out of the woods. There are thousands of index funds, and many of those are not true index funds. Most of them have problems in one way or another, such as liquidity risk, trading volume problems, risk of shutdown, tax inefficiency, mediocre fee percentages, tracking errors, index construction errors, and more. I know, it's exciting.

In addition to all of the different fund choice dilemmas, keep in mind that index funds can swing wildly, like stocks. Some of the well constructed index funds dropped over 70% from peak to trough from 2007 to 2009. Psychologically, 70% down and 90% down feel similar - when confronted with that situation your reaction will not be "I just dropped 70% but I'm feeling good because it's not 90%."

What to do? That's where index portfolio construction comes into play. You need many indexes (but not too many), and they each serve a dedicated purpose. In the investment work that I see inbound from new clients, the "serve a purpose" function is almost always missing from their previous advisors or brokers. What I see is collections of funds or stocks that are often not well diversified and are not serving as either protection points, dividend generators, or areas of future possible capital gain. Without those purposes, capital is going to waste.

In a well-constructed portfolio, each position has a dedicated reason for being there. By reason I do not mean "Jim Cramer threw a rubber chicken across the stage he was so excited about this stock, so my advisor put it in my account." By reason I mean it is there to protect you, to generate current cash for you, or to generate capital gains. And importantly, the purposes work in tension with each other. Sometimes a world event will be detrimental to one index, but another will do well. Envision a matrix, where the index funds are spread out to cover the possible scenarios that the future may hold.

What could go wrong? Short of a mushroom cloud on the horizon, a lot. Probably the most insidious, because it is quiet and usually doesn't make the news, is inflation. Ask anyone who lived through the 1970's what inflation did to their savings. Moving on in this list of rosy scenarios, we have financial panics, currency risk, wars, corruption in corporate America, unfavorable tax changes, trade and tariff conflicts, regional risks (think real estate crashes and cost of living), and others.

If all this talk about matrixes and tension seems abstract, let me use a real example. In a severe crash like 2008, almost everyone's assumptions fell apart. This led to increased panic as things became unfamiliar. Almost all stock index funds, all real estate index funds, all foreign index funds, and almost all bond funds started to buckle under the pressure, and then moved to outright collapse. But U.S. Treasuries did not behave this way. Those boring treasuries that never made you much money now seemed so attractive you'd practically ask them to the prom. Unlike everything else, they were rising, and quickly, as the entire world rushed to their embrace.

They served their purpose: they protected you, and they gave you cash when it was most valuable: in a panic. Their purpose was not to make you a lot of money in capital gains, their purpose was protection.

Every index we buy for you has a dedicated reason to either offset risk or make you money long term. If we cannot make a succinct and clear argument as to the distinct attributes of each position, we should not own it.

Return to Articles
DIFFERENTIATORS
GETTING STARTED
MATERIALS
How We Are Different
Understanding Your Financial Statement
Articles by Dan Cunningham
Investing with Low Cost Index Funds
Pay Yourself First
Why Use a Fiduciary Financial Advisor?
Vermont Financial Planning
Quarterly Booklets
Financial Planning
Investor Resources
Investment Tools
Financial Firm Comparison
The Investment Process
One Day In July in the Media
Local Financial Advisor
How to Switch Financial Advisors
Frequently Asked Questions
Book Recommendations
Types of Investors
One Day In July Careers
Prospect Booklet
Square Mailers
Fee Calculator
SERVICES
Types of Accounts We Manage
Options for Self-Employed Retirement Plans
Saving Strategies
What to do When Receiving a Pension
Investment Tax Strategy: Tax Loss Harvesting
Vermont Investment Management
How to Invest an Inheritance
Investment Tax Strategy: Tax Lot Optimization
Vermont Retirement Planning
How to Make the Best 401k Selections
Investing for Retirement: 401k and More
Vermont Wealth Management
How to Rollover a 401k to an IRA
Investing in Bennington, VT
Vermont Financial Advisors
Investing in Albany, NY
Investing in Saratoga Springs, NY
New Hampshire Financial Advisors
INVESTING THOUGHTS
Should I Try to Time the Stock Market?
Mutual Funds vs. ETFs
Inflation
The Cycle of Investor Emotion
Countering Arguments Against Index Funds
Annuities - Why We Don't Sell Them
Taxes on Investments
How Financial Firms Bill
Low Investment Fees
Retirement Financial Planning
Investing in a Bear Market
Investing in Gold
Is Your Investment Advisor Worth One Percent?
Active vs. Passive Investment Management
Investment Risk vs. Investment Return
Who Supports Index Funds?
Investing Concepts
Does Stock Picking Work?
The Growth and Importance of Female Investors
Behavioral Economics
The Forward P/E Ratio

Vergennes, VT Financial Advisors

206 Main Street, Suite 20

Vergennes, VT 05491

(802) 777-9768

Wayne, PA Financial Advisors

851 Duportail Rd, 2nd Floor

Chesterbrook, PA 19087

(610) 673-0074

Burlington, VT Financial Advisors

77 College Street, Suite 3A

Burlington, VT 05401

(802) 503-8280

Middlebury, VT Financial Advisors

79 Court Street, Suite 1

Middlebury, VT 05753

(802) 829-6954

Hanover, NH Financial Advisors

26 South Main Street, Suite 4

Hanover, NH 03755

(802) 341-0188

Rutland, VT Financial Advisors

734 E US Route 4, Suite 7

Rutland, VT 05701

(802) 829-6954


v 2.4.55 | © One Day In July LLC. All Rights Reserved.